User avatar
 
ManhattanPrepLSAT1
Thanks Received: 1909
Atticus Finch
Atticus Finch
 
Posts: 2863
Joined: October 07th, 2009
 
This post thanked 5 times.
 
 

Q20 - Only poetry cannot be translated

by ManhattanPrepLSAT1 Wed May 19, 2010 2:51 pm

This one is a great example of the creativity of the LSAT-writer.

While this argument is riddled with conditional relationships, I would not advocate diagramming this question using formal notation. The reason is that the terms shift from one relationship to another. In order to link chains of conditional logic together, we need to see the same term within two statements. In a basic form

A --> B
B --> C
======

then we could infer

A --> C

But we would only do this if the terms were repeated across several conditional relationships.

In this one, we don't see terms appearing and linking the relationships together.

We need to knock out each incorrect answer by testing it against the statements. We're fortunate in that each of the incorrect answers is almost exactly paraphrases one statement from the stimulus - making the comparison fairly simple.

The question stem asks us to find the one that is LEAST supported. Meaning that four of the answer choices can be inferred from the stimulus, the one that cannot is the correct answer choice. Think of this question as "must be true EXCEPT".

(A) can be inferred from the first sentence of the stimulus. If only poetry cannot be translated well, then if it is not poetry it can be translated well.
(B) is correct. This answer choice distorts the first sentence a bit. We know that poets preserve language, but we don't know that a purpose of writing poetry is to preserve language.
(C) can be inferred from the first sentence within the part, "for we would not bother to learn a language if we could get everything written in from translation."
(D) can be inferred from the claim, "we cannot witness the beauty of poetry except in the language in which it is composed."
(E) can be inferred from the claim, "Only poetry cannot be translated well."
 
SJK493
Thanks Received: 0
Jackie Chiles
Jackie Chiles
 
Posts: 29
Joined: May 14th, 2018
 
 
 

Re: Q20 - Only poetry cannot be translated

by SJK493 Mon Jul 23, 2018 12:27 am

Is there a difference between Cannot Be True and Must Be True Except?

I did not choose (B) because it says one purpose of writing poetry (not the only purpose) and felt that it Could Be True. So I would like to ask what the difference is between Cannot Be True questions where Could be True answers are acceptable and Must Be True Except questions.
 
AbhishekM843
Thanks Received: 0
Vinny Gambini
Vinny Gambini
 
Posts: 3
Joined: November 01st, 2018
 
 
 

Re: Q20 - Only poetry cannot be translated

by AbhishekM843 Mon Nov 05, 2018 12:18 pm

SJK493 wrote:Is there a difference between Cannot Be True and Must Be True Except?


Must Be True EXCEPT = Could Be False

So, ye, there is a slight difference between Could Be False and Cannot Be True. Whenever you see an except, trade must for a could and true for a false and vice versa to eliminate the except.

The question stem in this case is roughly saying, which choice is the Least Could Be True option. Least isn't the same thing as except.